Seigniorage, rebasing, and fractional designs compared, and why every algorithmic peg has failed under real redemption pressure.
Impermanent Loss (IL) occurs when providing liquidity to an AMM results in less value than simply holding the tokens. The loss is "impermanent" because it can be recovered if prices return to original levels.
Understanding IL
When you provide liquidity:
- You deposit two tokens in specific ratio
- AMM maintains price balance
- If prices change, AMM rebalances
- You end up with different ratio
- Value may be less than holding
IL Example
You provide liquidity to ETH/USDC pool:
- Deposit: 1 ETH ($2,000) + 2,000 USDC
- Total value: $4,000
ETH price doubles to $4,000:
- Pool rebalances to maintain ratio
- Your position: 0.707 ETH + 2,828 USDC
- Value if held: $4,000 + $2,000 = $6,000
- Value in pool: (0.707 × $4,000) + 2,828 = $5,656
- Impermanent Loss: $344 (5.7%)
IL Calculation
| Price Change | IL % |
|---|
| 1.25x | 0.6% |
| 1.50x | 2.0% |
| 2.00x | 5.7% |
| 3.00x | 13.4% |
| 4.00x | 20.0% |
| 5.00x | 25.5% |
Mitigating IL
Choose Stable Pairs
- Stablecoin pairs (USDC/USDT)
- Pegged assets (stETH/ETH)
- Minimal price divergence
- Uniswap V3 allows price ranges
- Narrower range = more fees but more IL risk
Consider Single-Sided
- Some protocols offer single-asset LP
- Less exposure to both tokens
High Fee Pools
- Higher trading fees offset IL
- Look for pools with high APR
IL vs Trading Fees
IL can be profitable if:
- Trading fees earned > IL
- Prices remain relatively stable
- You withdraw when prices normalize
IL Calculators
Tools to estimate IL:
- dailydefi.org/tools/impermanent-loss-calculator/
- defiyield.app/advanced-impermanent-loss-calculator
- coinculator.io/impermanent-loss-calculator/